Glock 42 vs. S&W Bodyguard: A Detailed Comparison for Concealed Carry
Choosing the right concealed carry pistol can be a daunting task, especially with so many options available on the market. Two popular choices often compared are the Glock 42 and the Smith & Wesson Bodyguard 380. Both are compact, lightweight, and chambered in .380 ACP, making them appealing for those seeking a comfortable and easily concealable firearm. However, they possess distinct differences that cater to varying preferences and needs. This article provides a comprehensive comparison of the Glock 42 and the S&W Bodyguard, examining their features, performance, and suitability for different concealed carry scenarios. We’ll delve into aspects like size, weight, ergonomics, trigger pull, accuracy, and reliability to help you make an informed decision.
Size and Weight: Concealability Matters
For a concealed carry pistol, size and weight are paramount. The Glock 42 is slightly larger than the S&W Bodyguard, but the difference is minimal. The Glock 42 measures approximately 5.94 inches in overall length, 4.13 inches in height, and 0.98 inches in width, weighing around 13.76 ounces unloaded. The S&W Bodyguard 380, on the other hand, is about 5.3 inches long, 4.1 inches high, and 1.1 inches wide, weighing approximately 12.3 ounces unloaded.
While the Bodyguard is slightly smaller and lighter, the difference is often negligible when carried. The Glock 42’s slightly larger frame can offer a more substantial grip for some shooters, potentially improving control and accuracy. The S&W Bodyguard‘s smaller size might be advantageous for those with smaller hands or who prioritize extreme concealability. Ultimately, the best choice depends on individual preferences and body type. Consider trying both pistols to see which feels more comfortable and conceals better for you.
Ergonomics and Handling
Ergonomics play a crucial role in how comfortable and controllable a pistol feels in hand. The Glock 42, being a Glock, features the familiar Glock grip angle and texture. Many find the Glock grip to be comfortable and secure, providing a consistent and repeatable grip. The S&W Bodyguard has a more rounded grip, which some may find more comfortable, especially for those with smaller hands. However, the Bodyguard’s grip texture can be less aggressive than the Glock 42’s, potentially affecting grip security, especially during rapid firing.
Both pistols feature relatively low recoil due to the .380 ACP cartridge. However, the Glock 42‘s slightly larger size and weight can help to absorb recoil better than the S&W Bodyguard. The slide serrations on both pistols are adequate for racking the slide, although some users may find the Glock 42’s serrations to be slightly more pronounced and easier to grip.
Trigger Performance: A Key Differentiator
The trigger is one of the most significant differences between the Glock 42 and the S&W Bodyguard. The Glock 42 features the Glock Safe Action trigger, a partially pre-cocked striker-fired system. The trigger pull is typically around 5.5 to 6.5 pounds, with a clean break and a short reset. Many shooters find the Glock trigger to be predictable and easy to master, contributing to improved accuracy.
The S&W Bodyguard, on the other hand, has a double-action-only (DAO) trigger. This means that the trigger pull is longer and heavier, typically around 8 to 10 pounds. The DAO trigger requires a deliberate and consistent pull, which can be challenging for some shooters, especially those accustomed to lighter triggers. While the heavier trigger is intended to enhance safety, it can negatively impact accuracy and speed, particularly during rapid fire. Dry firing the S&W Bodyguard extensively can help to smooth out the trigger pull over time.
Accuracy and Reliability
Accuracy is crucial for any firearm, especially a concealed carry pistol. The Glock 42 generally exhibits good accuracy for its size. Its longer sight radius and better trigger contribute to more precise shot placement. Many users report being able to consistently achieve tight groups at typical self-defense distances (7-10 yards) with the Glock 42.
The S&W Bodyguard can also be accurate, but the heavier DAO trigger can make it more challenging to achieve consistent results. With practice, shooters can become proficient with the Bodyguard, but it typically requires more effort than with the Glock 42. The shorter sight radius of the Bodyguard can also make it slightly more difficult to aim precisely.
Both the Glock 42 and the S&W Bodyguard are generally considered to be reliable pistols. However, some users have reported occasional malfunctions with the Bodyguard, particularly with certain types of ammunition. The Glock 42 has a reputation for being exceptionally reliable, even with a wide variety of ammunition. Regular cleaning and maintenance are essential for ensuring the reliability of any firearm.
Features and Accessories
The Glock 42 features the standard Glock sights, which are polymer and can be upgraded to aftermarket options like night sights. It also has a simple takedown procedure, making it easy to disassemble and clean. The Glock 42 benefits from a large aftermarket, with numerous options for holsters, sights, and other accessories.
The S&W Bodyguard features integrated sights, which are generally low-profile. Some models of the Bodyguard come with an integrated laser sight, which can be helpful for low-light conditions. However, the laser sight can also add to the overall bulk of the pistol. The aftermarket for the Bodyguard is not as extensive as the Glock 42, but there are still plenty of options available for holsters and other accessories.
Price and Value
The Glock 42 typically retails for slightly more than the S&W Bodyguard. However, the price difference is usually not significant. Both pistols offer good value for their price, considering their features and performance. The Glock 42’s reputation for reliability and accuracy may justify its slightly higher price for some buyers. The S&W Bodyguard’s smaller size and lower price point may make it a more attractive option for others. Consider your budget and priorities when making your decision.
Pros and Cons: A Quick Summary
Glock 42 Pros:
- Better trigger pull
- Greater accuracy potential
- Proven reliability
- Larger aftermarket
- More comfortable grip for some
Glock 42 Cons:
- Slightly larger and heavier than the Bodyguard
- Higher price point
S&W Bodyguard 380 Pros:
- Smaller and lighter
- Lower price point
- Integrated laser sight option
- More comfortable grip for some with smaller hands
S&W Bodyguard 380 Cons:
- Heavier DAO trigger
- Less accuracy potential
- Potentially less reliable
- Smaller aftermarket
Who Are These Pistols For?
The Glock 42 is an excellent choice for shooters who prioritize accuracy, reliability, and a good trigger pull. It’s a suitable option for those who are comfortable with the Glock platform and appreciate its simplicity and dependability. The Glock 42 is also a good choice for those who may eventually want to upgrade their sights or other components.
The S&W Bodyguard is a good option for shooters who prioritize extreme concealability and a lower price point. It’s a suitable choice for those with smaller hands or who are new to concealed carry. The S&W Bodyguard with the integrated laser sight can be a good option for those who anticipate using their firearm in low-light conditions.
Conclusion: Choosing the Right Pistol for You
The Glock 42 and the S&W Bodyguard are both viable options for concealed carry, each with its own strengths and weaknesses. The best choice depends on your individual needs, preferences, and shooting experience. Consider factors such as size, weight, ergonomics, trigger pull, accuracy, reliability, and price when making your decision. If possible, try both pistols at a range before making a purchase. Renting each model is a great way to assess them. [See also: Best Concealed Carry Holsters] Ultimately, the best concealed carry pistol is the one that you are most comfortable and proficient with.
Before purchasing any firearm, be sure to familiarize yourself with all applicable local, state, and federal laws. Seek professional training and practice regularly to maintain proficiency with your chosen firearm. The Glock 42 and S&W Bodyguard are tools, and like any tool, they require proper training and responsible handling. Remember, safe gun handling is paramount.
